Choose an agency around the problem you need to solve.

The questions that reveal how an agency thinks, works and measures progress.

Share

Name the business problem.

Before comparing proposals, write down what needs to change. Are the right people failing to discover you? Is the website attracting visitors but losing enquiries? Does the brand look inconsistent? Different problems call for different capabilities.

Bring context: your offer, audience, sales cycle, existing activity, team capacity and any available performance data. A useful agency conversation starts with these facts.

Ask how the work connects.

Branding, websites, content and paid media influence one another. Ask who takes responsibility for the connections. A campaign can attract the right audience and still underperform if the landing page is unclear or the follow-up is slow.

  • Who owns the strategy and the day-to-day delivery?
  • What do we need to supply or approve?
  • How are changes to scope handled?
  • Which accounts and source files will we control?

Look past the headline metric.

Reach, impressions and traffic can be useful signals. They do not automatically mean useful demand. Ask how the team will distinguish relevant enquiries from noise and what evidence is available to connect marketing to commercial outcomes.

Be cautious with fixed promises made before the agency understands your offer, market and budget. A thoughtful explanation of assumptions is more useful than an impressive number with no context.

Make the proposal easy to compare.

A good scope names deliverables, responsibilities, exclusions, review points and dependencies. It separates advertising spend, production costs and agency fees where relevant. It also explains how progress will be discussed.

For a local business, ask how the team approaches location relevance. For an international engagement, agree communication windows, approvals and the practical details of remote collaboration.

Start with a shared definition of progress.

Agree the problem, the first priorities, the evidence you will review and the next decision. This gives both teams a fair basis for evaluating the relationship and makes the work easier to improve.

Bring a brief, not a shopping list.

A useful starting brief explains the goal, the audience, the constraint and what success would look like.

Give competing proposals the same brief

Ask each team to respond to the same starting point. Share the priority audience, the action you want more people to take, what is currently in place and what counts as a useful enquiry. Request a scope for the first phase and what they need from your side to begin. Compare who owns approvals, design, measurement and handover. A low price can reflect fewer actual deliverables or dependencies your team will need to cover. A broad proposal can cover more than you can review in the first month. Identify the gaps before comparing the totals.

Evaluate the first report before buying a retainer

Ask what a monthly report would tell you about budget decisions and how numbers would be checked. For paid lead generation, ask how the team separates form submissions from qualified calls and how it learns which enquiries turn into conversations. For search, ask which pages and types of query they will track and how they will distinguish a demand change from a website change. Agree the baseline, review cadence and who has access to the source accounts. If you are new to a working relationship, a well-defined audit or pilot can establish the first useful proof and clarify what to keep, change or stop.